The 3 Stalins
At Yalta in February of 1945 and then Potsdam in the summer of that year, the United Kingdom, Russia and the United States agreed to carve up Europe into the well known "spheres of influence", ushering in the beginning of the Cold War. Initially led by an ailing Roosevelt who was happy to give Stalin undue consideration, Truman who assumed the leadership of United States at Potsdam was out of his league. After all, his Secretary of State (Byrnes) was his poker playing buddy of many years, and neither one of them were geopolitically astute. The dynamic of a mistrustful Ch urchill, having lost the election to Attlee, gave way for the UK milk toast Attlee to agree to Stalin's terms and conditions.
Granted, Britain, having carried the can on the war in Europe for the allies and Russia suffering massive losses fighting the battles in the East for as many years, were weary of war. The American mindset, based upon it's powerful military industrial complex and eventual success in the Pacific following the one attack on it's soil, not to mention the atomic bomb, was one of misguided invincibility, no matter what happened across the pond.
While there are parallels to the geopolitical matrix of today, there are many differences, especially in the leadership of the three most powerful nations. Where the leaders in 1945 were all outclassed by Stalin, one leader, who fancies himself a powerful autocrat like Stalin, is outclassed by the two other Stalins of our time. Being consumed by his own image, and flushed with pride that he is allowed to sit with Xi and Putin, Trump has no idea he is being hoodwinked by these crafty Machiavellian autocrats.
Moreover, the most disconcerting aspect of this so-called "summit" is the credibility that Putin derives just in being there.
If we parse the statements from Vladimir Putin in the recent China gathering, we get a very clear picture of his unwavering intent.
“Inevitable changes and a shift in the centre of gravity in the global economic balance are not always perceived appropriately,” Mr. Putin said in a speech Wednesday, hailing a new geopolitical order.
“Instead of adapting to these opportunities, former hegemonies seek to curb the development of those demonstrating success and progress, contrary to the logic of fair competition and, frankly, sometimes even contrary to their own interests.”
He (Putin) said Europe was facing “humiliating decline” and dismissed the heavy sanctions imposed against Russia by the West as a result of the war in Ukraine, saying “practice has shown that the former instruments of economic domination and de facto coercion have outlived their usefulness and largely lost their effectiveness.” Trump arrives in China to historic red carpet welcome by Xi, The Globe and Mail November 18, 2026.
The message is crystal clear: 1: The once strong capitalistic systems and democracies are failing (as predicted by Karl Marx); 2: These systems, suffer from incoherent and weak alliances; 3: These systems do not recognize that they are failing and if they realized their failure they could be more powerful (pandering to Trump); and 4: Russia can outlast any of your petty sanctions, while you languish in indecision and inaction (Europe), and regain the territory to which it rightfully belongs.
Putin's statements are obtuse, which would go well over Trump's head. However, make no mistake, they are chillingly provocative. Europe also needs to take notice - more action and fewer words to counter this very real intent at their door step.
A communist and autocrat may paint himself as a wise and realistic student of geopolitics. but by any colour he is still a believer in the demise of capitalism and the triumph of state centred autocracy.
Xi is more circumspect, but this view fits squarely with his own. He will not play his cards so boldly and like most Chinese leaders before him, his system is in its ascendency and will outlast competing systems.
Clearly we are facing the new Cold War. When we are left with the two Stalins our quest remains.
Consequently, what is Canada's place in this new geopolitical reality? Prime Minister Carney has carved this out very methodically. The realpolitik of aligning ourselves with like minded middle powers is a start, and he has wasted no time is building those bridges.
His government's policies to rebuild our defense capabilities, linking them with opportunities for Canadian industries puts potential traffic on those bridges. Promoting existing trade agreements and making new ones facilitate access to global markets for these and other products. It will be up to Canadian businesses seize the opportunities - and there is ample assistance for them to generate tangible results (BDC, Global Affairs are two examples).
The Arctic remains our Achilles Heel, especially when it comes to the competing interests of Russia and China and our investment in that geopolitical flashpoint needs to be emphasized and underscored. The cold war will it's coldest in this part of our territory.
Cooperation with the US will continue where required and in our mutual interest. The difference will be that it will no longer be the default to take a free ride on their coattails.
Canada strong needs to be more than a slogan; it will require ongoing commitment over decades, to live up to our anthem and solidify our reputation in the global community.
The Stalins of the world require effective, tacit and substantive resistance and we cannot evade that responsibility to ourselves and the global community.
Comments
Post a Comment